按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
fashion of thought places such writings in their hands； will the
so…called convictions of their youth stand firm？ The young thinker；
who has in his armoury none but dogmatical weapons with which to
resist the attacks of his opponent； and who cannot detect the latent
dialectic which lies in his own opinions as well as in those of the
opposite party； sees the advance of illusory arguments and grounds
of proof which have the advantage of novelty； against as illusory
grounds of proof destitute of this advantage； and which； perhaps；
excite the suspicion that the natural credulity of his youth has
been abused by his instructors。 He thinks he can find no better
means of showing that he has out grown the discipline of his
minority than by despising those well…meant warnings； and； knowing
no system of thought but that of dogmatism； he drinks deep draughts of
the poison that is to sap the principles in which his early years were
trained。
Exactly the opposite of the system here remended ought to be
pursued in academical instruction。 This can only be effected； however；
by a thorough training in the critical investigation of pure reason。
For； in order to bring the principles of this critique into exercise
as soon as possible； and to demonstrate their perfect even in the
presence of the highest degree of dialectical illusion； the student
ought to examine the assertions made on both sides of speculative
questions step by step； and to test them by these principles。 It
cannot be a difficult task for him to show the fallacies inherent in
these propositions； and thus he begins early to feel his own power
of securing himself against the influence of such sophistical
arguments； which must finally lose； for him； all their illusory power。
And； although the same blows which overturn the edifice of his
opponent are as fatal to his own speculative structures； if such he
has wished to rear； he need not feel any sorrow in regard to this
seeming misfortune； as he has now before him a fair prospect into
the practical region in which he may reasonably hope to find a more
secure foundation for a rational system。
There is； accordingly； no proper polemic in the sphere of pure
reason。 Both parties beat the air and fight with their own shadows； as
they pass beyond the limits of nature； and can find no tangible
point of attack… no firm footing for their dogmatical conflict。
Fight as vigorously as they may； the shadows which they hew down；
immediately start up again； like the heroes in Walhalla； and renew the
bloodless and unceasing contest。
But neither can we admit that there is any proper sceptical
employment of pure reason； such as might be based upon the principle
of neutrality in all speculative disputes。 To excite reason against
itself； to place weapons in the hands of the party on the one side
as well as in those of the other； and to remain an undisturbed and
sarcastic spectator of the fierce struggle that ensues； seems； from
the dogmatical point of view； to be a part fitting only a malevolent
disposition。 But； when the sophist evidences an invincible obstinacy
and blindness； and a pride which no criticism can moderate； there is
no other practicable course than to oppose to this pride and obstinacy
similar feelings and pretensions on the other side； equally well or
ill founded； so that reason； staggered by the reflections thus
forced upon it； finds it necessary to moderate its confidence in
such pretensions and to listen to the advice of criticism。 But we
cannot stop at these doubts； much less regard the conviction of our
ignorance； not only as a cure for the conceit natural to dogmatism；
but as the settlement of the disputes in which reason is involved with
itself。 On the contrary； scepticism is merely a means of awakening
reason from its dogmatic dreams and exciting it to a more careful
investigation into its own powers and pretensions。 But； as
scepticism appears to be the shortest road to a permanent peace in the
domain of philosophy； and as it is the track pursued by the many who
aim at giving a philosophical colouring to their contemptuous
dislike of all inquiries of this kind； I think it necessary to present
to my readers this mode of thought in its true light。
Scepticism not a Permanent State for Human Reason。
The consciousness of ignorance… unless this ignorance is
recognized to be absolutely necessary ought； instead of forming the
conclusion of my inquiries； to be the strongest motive to the
pursuit of them。 All ignorance is either ignorance of things or of the
limits of knowledge。 If my ignorance is accidental and not
necessary； it must incite me； in the first case； to a dogmatical
inquiry regarding the objects of which I am ignorant； in the second；
to a critical investigation into the bounds of all possible knowledge。
But that my ignorance is absolutely necessary and unavoidable； and
that it consequently absolves from the duty of all further
investigation； is a fact which cannot be made out upon empirical
grounds… from observation… but upon critical grounds alone； that is；
by a thoroughgoing investigation into the primary sources of
cognition。 It follows that the determination of the bounds of reason
can be made only on a priori grounds； while the empirical limitation
of reason； which is merely an indeterminate cognition of an
ignorance that can never be pletely removed； can take place only
a posteriori。 In other words； our empirical knowledge is limited by
that which yet remains for us to know。 The former cognition of our
ignorance； which is possible only on a rational basis； is a science；
the latter is merely a perception； and we cannot say how far the
inferences drawn from it may extend。 If I regard the earth； as it
really appears to my senses； as a flat surface； I am ignorant how
far this surface extends。 But experience teaches me that； how far
soever I go； I always see before me a space in which I can proceed
farther； and thus I know the limits… merely visual… of my actual
knowledge of the earth； although I am ignorant of the limits of the
earth itself。 But if I have got so far as to know that the earth is
a sphere； and that its sur